Bank made reasonable inquiries before approving reverse home loan

Categories:
Advice & information, Lending,
Summary:
In September 2016, Murphy and Kelly, who were then in their 60s, applied for a reverse home loan over their mortgage-free home, which was valued at $945,000. Under such a loan, they would not make any regular repayments. Instead, the bank would add interest to the balance, which would grow over the years and be repaid when they sold the home.
Published:
November 2026

The bank approved a loan of up to $167,000, secured by a mortgage over their property. They drew on $50,000 immediately to repay car loans, leaving $117,000 for later. They chose not to protect a fixed proportion of the home's value that the loan could not encroach on. Without this so-called equity protection, the loan balance could keep growing and potentially absorb all of the home's value. In 2018, Murphy and Kelly began drawing on the $117,000 available to them in order to help cover living expenses, and by August 2024 they had drawn on all of it, leaving them with a debt of $295,000.

Some time later, Murphy moved into a care home, and Kelly wanted to sell the home and buy another one. At this point, their son-in-law learned about the reverse home loan. He complained on their behalf that the bank had not properly asked whether the loan suited their needs. He said it should have asked about keeping equity for their estate and future housing and aged care options. He also questioned why the bank approved $167,000 when they needed only $50,000, and said it should have reassessed the suitability of the loan each time Murphy and Kelly drew on the $117,000. He said the loan had left Kelly unable to buy a comparable home locally.

Our investigation

The loan application form recorded details about the bank's inquiries. It showed that the couple’s expenses were more than their income, that they had no other savings, that they did not want to make repayments, and that they wanted to borrow the maximum amount the bank would lend. The form recorded that downsizing was not an option. It also recorded that Murphy and Kelly did not want to protect any of the equity in their home. Their son-in-law maintained that someone at the bank had added this answer about equity protection five days after Murphy and Kelly had signed the application form, pointing to an initialled change dated after they had signed the form. We found that this merely showed the bank had obtained answers to incomplete sections after the couple had signed the form, not that it had failed to ask the questions. Kelly’s later belief that she would be left with some equity was inconsistent with the contract she had signed. Reverse home loans grow quickly, so a bank should ask about borrowers' plans for their equity. However, a bank needs only satisfy itself that such a loan is likely to meet a customer’s needs – which Murphy and Kelly's bank did. It did not need to be their best option. Accordingly, we found the bank had made reasonable inquiries.

We also found that the bank gave them appropriate information about the type of loan they were taking out. A separate contract the couple signed explained the key terms in plain language. Murphy and Kelly initialled a "STOP – before you sign" page. It asked them to consider aged care and their estate, listed other options and strongly recommended financial advice. They had recorded that financial advice was "not necessary". A lawyer gave them independent legal advice and certified that he had no reason to think they did not understand the terms of the loan.

The bank did not need to reassess the loan before each occasion when Murphy and Kelly subsequently drew on the loan. Each one was within the limit approved in 2016.

Murphy and Kelly still had $1.05 million of equity, which was more than their home was worth in 2016. She expected to have $900,000 left after the sale of the home, which she said was not enough for the home she wanted. We told her she could ask the bank to seek a loan on a new property and encouraged her to discuss her options with the bank.

Outcome

We did not uphold Murphy and Kelly's complaint.

Print this page